Friday, November 20, 2026

Short-Arming


Boys were playing together as they often do, running, debating, forming and re-forming "teams." Being the day before a long weekend, about half the kids were not at school, off on their travels or entertaining out of town guests. It was nearing the end of the day and the adults were mostly chatting among themselves, already shifting into long weekend mode, a great time to be a kid.

I watched one of the guys scoop up water in the blade of his shovel, then toss it toward a friend. I say toward rather than at because although it may have looked as if he was attempting to douse his buddy, I could tell that he short-armed the effort, causing the spray of water to land on the ground near the feet of his ostensible target, who replied with a good natured, "Hey!"

Periodically, what looked like sword fighting erupted, everyone swinging their shovels and stick ponies and broom handles at one another in ways that typically cause adults to step in with cautions, if not outright commands to "stop!" Sure, it would have hurt had someone been hit, but the reality was that those sticks were rarely coming within a foot of making actual contact with a person, and if you really studied what the kids were doing, you would find that they, again, were short-arming their efforts, not swinging full force, targeting one another's sticks, rather than their bodies. Accidents could happen, of course, but they were all striving to make sure they didn't, in what was a complex ballet of battle.


Occasionally, one boy would "capture" another, which meant wrapping him up in a bear hug. Then they would yell, "Stop!" or "I don't like that!" The boys rarely released their prisoner on the first voiced objection, usually not responding until the third "Stop!" or "I don't like that!" 

Although it might have seemed at first glance that the boys were ignoring their friends' objections, I found that they invariably released their holds within a few seconds. They were listening, even if they weren't always responding as quickly as their friends wanted. Again, a sort of short-arming.

That's what this kind of play is all about. It's why it's best when adults don't jump in so often and so promptly, at least when we're talking about four and five year olds. 

When children are younger, say two or three, many are still developing the capacity for short-arming, which is why they sometimes go too far with their classmates, physically and emotionally, often without any apparent provocation. 

They aren't trying to hurt their friends, but rather are experimenting with the limitations of friendship itself, figuring out how far one can go: only then can they begin to calculate how to short-arm in the future. This is when adults most effectively intervene, protecting children, while offering informative statements like, "When you hit people it hurts them," and "When I knock over someone's building, I help them build it again." We say these things not because we necessarily expect these very young children to spontaneously apologize (although they often do, in their own way) or to drop to their knees and help re-create whatever tower has been demolished (although they often do, in their own way), but rather to plant seeds that will, if consistently and lovingly tended, result in the kind of self-control that leads to short-arming.

At one point, a boy, with a smile on his face, shoved his friend to the ground. It was a hard shove, too hard, not at all short-armed, and it happened right in front of a group of chatting, vacation-ready adults. Had this happened when I was the only adult present, I'd have likely stood back for a moment to see how things played out, but in this case I knew that if I didn't make an effort to respond, someone else would, so I stepped toward the boys. As I did, I could see a face of anguish, we all could. Before I could take two steps, the boy who had done the pushing, dropped to his knees beside his friend saying, "Are you okay?"

Through his tears, "No."

"I'm sorry." When he received no response other than more tears, he again said, "I'm sorry." When he still received no response he asked, "What can I do?" These were my words coming out of him.

This time he received a response, "I want you to apologize."

Without hesitation, he said, "I'm sorry . . . I've said it three times!"

The boys lay there together on the ground for a couple minutes, then the drive to play again took the upper hand. 

Learning to play with the other people is the work of a lifetime. Next time, or the time after that, or the time after that, he'll short-arm that shove and a good natured, "Hey!" will be all that remains of the tears.

******

I've been writing about play-based learning almost every day for the past 14 years. I've recently gone back through the 4000+ blog posts(!) I've written since 2009. Here are my 10 favorite in a nifty free download. Click here to get yours.


I put a lot of time and effort into this blog. If you'd like to support me please consider a small contribution to the cause. Thank you!

No comments: