Teaching Self-Governance

(A while back I posted my Greatest Hits as determined by readership statistics, which then got me thinking about older posts that I wish more people had read, which has now become a sort of irregular series. I can't remember the last time I heard one of our elected representatives talk about education in anything other than economic terms. Preparing children for their economic lives is all well and good, but in this democratic experiment we have going here, that really shouldn't be the focus of what our schools are teaching our children. In this post, which was originally published in September 2010 under the title Teaching Democracy Through Play, I try to articulate my belief that a play-based curriculum is the best way for children to learn the skills necessary for self-governance. At the bottom of this post you'll find links to other posts in this series of posts I wish more people had read.)

I must run in the right circles because I keep hearing that there are people out there who are skeptical, even antagonistic, toward the idea that play is the natural way for children to learn, but I've never met any of them. Or maybe people just avoid the topic with me, you know, the way you don't bring up the subject of Monty Python or The Lord of the Rings with some people because it will be the topic that consumes the rest of the evening. Or maybe, and this would really make me sad, they don't think preschool is important enough to worry about.

"The very existence of youth is due in part to the necessity for

play; the animal does not play because he is young, he has a

period of youth because he must play." ~Karl Groos

There are business guys out there who are looking to our schools to train their workers for them and if that were the only purpose of education, I suppose, we could just put them on an assembly line and let our quality control team remove the defective ones in the interest of producing the best blueberry ice cream in the world. But there is so much more to a real education than mere vocational training. In fact, I would argue that preparing children for jobs is a small, perhaps incidental, part of what school should be about, especially public education.

There is no adult there to help these guys crossing the bridge

in opposite directions. They've already democratically determined,

along with their fellow citizens of our little self-governing society,

that they will live in a world where might does not make right,

so they are left to stand there, face-to-face and talk it through.

The reason we have public schools in the first place is for the purposes of the grand experiment of democracy, a well-educated populace being the foundation of self-governance. We are not here primarily to create workers, we are here to create thoughtful, questioning, critical, and yes, assertive citizens, ones who understand the people, and only the people, can make important decisions.

Self-governance requires an understanding of the subtleties of

sharing resources and space with others. These guys are working

out the complex balance between one man's right to build with

another's right to be secure in his own physical space.

People who have been poorly educated in the principles of democracy have a hard time with this notion. It frightens them, I think. They don't understand how the world can work without some kind "iron fist" of leaders or, at least, strict hierarchies. People of different faiths or ethnicities or class make them fear that their own faith or ethnicity or class is besieged.

These girls found a box in the corner, closed, and opened it. They knew

they didn't need to ask anyone for permission because they've come to 

understand that this classroom belongs to them, the citizens of 

Woodland Park. Inside they found something new: building blocks

that allowed them to seek their own path, not one pre-determined

by the dictatorship of those big wooden blocks.

A well-educated citizen understands that the challenges presented by our differences are also our greatest strength, but only if we are firmly convinced of the truth that all men are created equal, not just in the eyes of god, but in the eyes of one another. This does not, of course, mean that everyone gets their own way all the time, but it does mean that we get to argue for our own point of view, to have our voices heard. It also means that we must negotiate, compromise and, yes, sometimes even step aside.

Sometimes we need help figuring things out as we play, 

because it is serious business. As teachers we step in, not as

"bosses" or HR departments with solutions that come directly from 

the employee manual, but with listening ears,questioning words, and 

respect for our fellow citizens. The goal is not to impose 

peace, but to rather help clarify the situation so the two parties

can hammer out their own compromise.

Play as a curriculum is the only way I know to imbue students with these citizenship skills. No amount of testing or drilling or lecturing will get us there, although it might well produce docile, productive workers. You can't learn the skills needed for self-governance from flash cards or rote memorization or being put on an educational "fast track." No, the only way to learn the skills needed for democracy is through the kind of experience that comes from the real world laboratory of playing with your fellow citizens.

And, indeed, the skills of citizenship are often diametrically opposed to those expected of mere workers. Citizens must know that it is not only their right, but their responsibility, to question authority.

And when we do that, guys like Bill Gates call us their "enemy," which tells me were doing the right thing.

Can You Teach Me?

We Are Only Two

Mister Rogers

Rebellion Is Built Into Us

The Real Life For Which We Prepare Children

Courage To Screw Things Up

I put a lot of time and effort into this blog. If you'd like to support me please consider a small contribution to the cause. Thank you!