Tuesday, November 03, 2026

Maybe . . .

As a boy, we heard a lot about the so-called "population bomb," a term used to describe apocalyptic predictions that without drastic action to curtail birthrates around the world, we would face mass starvation by the mid-80s. 

It was a bomb that didn't explode according to predictions as birthrates then declined in what some identify as one of the most significant demographic developments in human history. From the perspective of today, we can see that global population growth peaked at about 2.1 percent annually in the late 60s, then began a rapid decline, falling to 1.08 percent by 2019.

There are many reasons that this happened, including the empowerment of girls and women, better access to contraception, declining infant mortality rates, urbanization, rising prosperity, changing cultural expectations, government policies, and, probably, to a certain degree, the apocalyptic predictions themselves, which likely caused at least some people to not want to bring children into a world of starvation. We see a similar response to apocalyptic predictions about climate change today as some young people are opting out of parenthood explicitly because they see a grim future for humanity.

The philosopher Alan Watts popularized a version of an ancient Chinese parable that seems particularly apt:

A farmer's horse ran away. His neighbors came to console him. "What terrible luck!" they said.

"Maybe," replied the farmer.

The next day, the horse returned, bringing several wild horses with it. "What wonderful luck!" exclaimed the neighbors.

"Maybe," said the farmer.

The following day, the farmer's son was thrown while trying to ride one of the wild horses, breaking his leg. "What terrible luck!" the neighbors said.

"Maybe," replied the farmer.

Soon afterward, war broke out and the army came to conscript the village's young men. Because of his broken leg, the farmer's son was spared. "What wonderful luck!" said the neighbors.

"Maybe," replied the farmer.

In his book How the World Really Works, scientist and author Vaclav Smil discusses the challenge of making predictions about any complex system, offering dozens of examples of how even seemingly well-supported predictive models typically miss the mark, often dramatically.

"(E)ven short-term projections involving complex systems . . . remain highly uncertain, and even near-term outlooks result in a broad range of possible outcomes." He even shows how today's sophisticated computer models are built on assumptions which can, and do, lead our predictions about the future astray, perhaps even more so than "pen-and-paper" calculations.

As it happens, I'm posting this on the morning of Election Day, when we will discover how closely the results align with the predictions of pollsters and pundits. Whatever happens, the story will continue, and tomorrow we'll all be making new predictions.

Of course, we all would like to know the future, and we can't help but anticipate and plan for it, but when the rubber meets the road, the most intellectually defensible response to confident predictions about our collective future, no matter how apocalyptic or Pollyannaish, is "Maybe."

The story continues and we, ourselves, stand within the complex system of life.

In his masterpiece War and Peace, Leo Tolstoy takes a similar view of how we view the past. So often, our history books focus on stories of individuals exerting their will, making it happen. As Tolstoy tells it, Napoleon imagines that he is directing events, but he is caught up in a complex system of circumstances, individual decisions, accidents, misunderstandings, and forces beyond anyone's comprehension. His generals issue orders, but by the time these orders reach the battlefield, the circumstances have changed. Soldiers must respond to what is immediately in front of them. Battles unfold through countless interactions, none of which can be understood in isolation. History doesn't go according to anyone's plan; it is simply what happens . . . Maybe.

Smil shows us the limits of our ability to predict the future, while Tolstoy is concerned with the limits of our ability to explain the past. We naively assert that hindsight gives us 20/20 vision, but the narratives we create after the fact, inevitably lead us to favor one set of individuals and events over others, while overlooking the countless other "reasons."

Yesterday, I wrote about a couple of boys who were disrupting the classroom with their game of "bad guys." These two "sweet" boys had created a relationship that produced a behavior that no one could have predicted by observing either child individually. Indeed, it confounded their parents who insisted that the "fault" must lie with the other boy. But their relationship wasn't something that just happened between the two of them. It included their parents, the rest of the children, me, a wider world in which "bad guys" were a thing, and countless other factors. As an active part of this system, I managed to bring their relationship into conversation with the larger community, and in doing so, new possibilities emerged that no one could have predicted.

The solution was not to correct their collective mind, but to expand it.

This is, I think, what the Chinese farmer does. Each new development expands the story, making moot the previous judgments of "good luck" or "bad luck." What seemed certain becomes uncertain. 

At the end of the day, perhaps we are no better at being able to explain why the past happened than we are at knowing what the future holds.

As adults who work with young children, we concern ourselves with their futures. Our schools strive to make children "school ready" or "college ready" or "career ready." Our policymakers are forever talking about those mythological "jobs of tomorrow." We worry what this or that behavior portends for their future prospects, worrying that their "bad guy" games will lead them to some sort of apocalyptic future; or that learning to read earlier than their peers portends glory. 

"Maybe." It is neither a statement of pessimism nor optimism, but rather an acknowledgment that the only thing we can ever really know is right now. Of course, we still try to learn from the past and prepare for the future, but at the end of the day, we can only act according to the moment that is emerging in front of us.

This is the great opportunity of the early years. Young children are neither cornucopians nor catastrophists. They are more firmly fixed in the present than we adults with our vast experience with pasts and futures that preoccupy us as life itself emerges before us. They are less committed than we are to the stories they've constructed about the past and future. A block becomes a telephone, then a jet, then a slice of cake. The meaning of an object remains open. The next moment can change everything.

Young children are especially adept at keeping possibilities open, which is precisely what the Chinese farmer does.

Folk singer and storyteller Utah Phillips quoted Mark Twain as saying, "Those of you who are inclined to worry have the widest selection in history." 

It's one of those lines that remains evergreen as our predictions and interpretations come and go. The opportunity, however, is for us to strive to approach our work with children, recognizing that they offer us a perspective of the emerging present that we struggle to grasp. It's a perspective in which there is no "ahead" or "behind," in which the past is never fully explainable and the future is unpredictable, so why not live right now and remain open to what happens next?

Our word apocalypse, which has come to signify the end of the world, comes from the Ancient Greek word apokálypsis, which originally meant "unveiling" or "revelation." That is the ultimate power of "Maybe."

******

Even the most thriving play-based environments can grow stale at times. I've created this collection of my favorite free (or nearly free) resources for educators, parents, and others who work with young children. It's my gift to you! Click here to download your own copy and never run out of ideas again!

I put a lot of time and effort into this blog. If you'd like to support me please consider a small contribution to the cause. Thank you!

No comments:

Post a Comment